Favourite Ads Rankings Test The Value Of Familiar Creative
Australia's Telstra and New Zealand's One NZ lead TRA's latest favourite-ads rankings with recognisable creative worlds. The result raises a useful question for CMOs: when does continuity improve brand recognition, and how should that be measured against campaign outcomes?
The Research Agency (TRA) released new Favourite Ads rankings on November 17, 2026, with Telstra rising to first place in Australia and One New Zealand holding the lead across the Tasman. Both top-ranked campaigns use familiar storytelling devices rather than an entirely new creative language, according to the agency's Australian and New Zealand results.
That makes the rankings useful evidence about audience preference and creative recognition. It does not make them a sales-effectiveness league table. For marketing leaders, the question is what to preserve from campaigns that people recognise, and what additional proof is needed before investing in the next chapter.
Recognisable Assets Outlast Individual Executions
The Australian ranking put Telstra's animation first after it placed fifth in April. Youi's recurring car-interview format ranked second, followed by Allianz, Budget Direct and RACQ. The results suggest recurring creative devices can help brands re-enter viewers' attention without introducing themselves from scratch each time.
TRA reported that 85% of respondents found the Telstra brand easy to identify in its ad. That figure rose to 90% for Youi and 98% for Budget Direct. Those are study-specific recognition measures, rather than universal recognition rates or sales results. Their commercial usefulness depends on whether the same devices remain distinctive outside a survey setting.
TRA group business director Alex Forrester argued that when audiences already recognise characters or a style, the next execution can get straight to its story. A returning cast can provide continuity, but familiarity alone does not make a weak new message more persuasive.
New Zealand Shows How A Story Can Keep Its Audience
One NZ kept first place with Chapter 3 of McCann's 'Let's Get Connected', after Chapter 2 led the April ranking. Kiwibank's 'Buck the System' entered second, ahead of ANZ, ASB and 2degrees. For One NZ, a continuing narrative appears to have kept the brand recognisable while giving viewers another instalment to follow.
In TRA's New Zealand evaluation, 37% described One NZ's ad as having a great story, against a norm of 17%. Meanwhile, 59% found ANZ's 'We Do How' execution funny, versus a reported norm of 15%. These are different creative-response measures; neither establishes how much customer acquisition or market share changed.
One NZ marketing leader Georgia Mahaffie credited consistency across executions. The underlying decision for brand teams is selective continuity: keep characters and cues that audiences connect to the brand, while letting the plot and product reasons to care evolve.
Looking for World-Class PR & Comms in APAC?
Tailored service packages for select brands and agencies.
Preference Is Not The Same As Business Effectiveness
The findings come from TRA's unprompted question about people's favourite advertising. A nationally representative sample of more than 1,000 Australians and 1,000 New Zealanders participated in the two markets, according to the published spring findings. The research identifies popular creative, not incremental revenue or the return on media spend.
TRA's Creative Edge framework also considers whether an ad is Remarkable, Rewarding and Remembered. Those dimensions can help explain how a creative platform earns attention and brand attribution. They should not be confused with a controlled test of whether the campaign changed purchasing behaviour.
For a CMO, the distinction matters when budgets tighten. A much-liked ad that viewers cannot attribute to the advertiser may contribute less to the brand than its entertainment value suggests. Equally, a recognisable campaign can still underperform on response if the product promise or customer experience does not hold up.
The CMO Decision Is What To Carry Forward
Regional marketers should audit which creative elements are already doing identification work. Distinctive animation, a returning cast or a consistent narrative structure can be measured across successive ads. That audit should be paired with brand attribution, consideration and commercial response rather than a single preference rank.
A practical test would compare recognition and campaign outcomes across new executions while holding key conditions as consistent as possible. The same creative world need not mean identical scripts in Sydney and Auckland: local humour, channel choices and product needs can change while brand cues remain recognisable.
The November rankings give Telstra and One NZ evidence that their creative platforms are memorable to surveyed audiences. The next question for their marketing teams, and the agencies advising them, is which familiar assets also contribute to measurable business results. That is a stronger case for continuity than a top-five ranking alone.
Want to reach thousands of marketing and comms professionals across Asia?
Get your brand in front of industry decision-makers.
Partner with Mission Media →